After a guilty decision

Appealing an NYC parking ticket decision

A guilty decision at your hearing is not the last word. The Parking Violations Appeals Board — three administrative law judges — reviews hearing decisions. The appeal is by mail, and the deadline is the whole game: within 30 calendar days of the hearing decision.

The rules

Where it goes

With payment enclosed: NYC Department of Finance, Adjudication Division, P.O. Box 3615, Church Street Station, New York, NY 10008-3615. Without payment: Adjudication Division — Appeals Unit, 66 John Street, 3rd Floor, New York, NY 10038. In-person appeals are heard at 66 John Street, 3rd Floor, Monday to Friday, 9:00 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. The Appeals Board's emergency phone is (212) 361-5990.

Grounds that move a board

Strongest first: an error of law — above all, a required element the ticket lacked that the hearing judge let pass; a decision against the weight of your documents, where the decision never engaged the evidence; new evidence that could not have been produced at the hearing; and procedural failures, like being denied the chance to present evidence. Disagreeing with the judge's reading of the same facts, by itself, is the weakest ground there is.

Money while you wait

After the board decides, you have 30 days to pay with no additional penalties; if you paid and the appeal wins, the refund is automatic within 30 days. Know the risk plainly: penalties and interest may keep accruing while an appeal is pending — many owners pay and appeal for the refund. Past the board, the last road is an Article 78 case in New York Supreme Court, within 4 months of the appeal decision.

The Dispute Packet's appeal part walks the whole filing: the grounds in order, what to write, and the checklist of what to send. See the packet.

Process and addresses verified against the Department of Finance, November 20, 2026.